James Maguire, writer: movies, books, pop culture

TV interviews:

james maguire, jon stewart, daily show
James Maguire on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart

james maguire, msnbc interview about Ed Sullivan biography
James Maguire on MSNBC

james maguire, abc
James Maguire on ABC

james maguire, newshour, news hour, jim lehrer
James Maguire on The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer

james maguire, cnn
James Maguire on CNN

Some of my favorite people/things/sites:

Maguire sibs online:

Creation Production Co.
My brother Matthew, and my sister-in-law, Susan Mosakowski, wildly creative playwrights in New York City

Michael B. Maguire
My brother Mike, a big time lawyer guy - don't cross him in a court of law

Mary Maguire
My sister Mary, a cool professor of Criminal Justice at California State University, Sacramento

Notable notables:

WaltNow
The effervescent humor of Walt Jaschek

Borowitz Report
My favorite satirist; Andy Borowitz is an important voice

Mediabistro
A gathering of writer-media types

Publisher's Weekly
The book biz

Slate
Intelligent life online

Metacritic
Reviews of movies, books, TV

Arts & Letters Daily
Articles about everything

Technorati
The Top 100 blogs

Mark Twain
A quote from the master

James Joyce
The lyric conclusion of Ulysses

Links
Yup, we got links


« Enigmatic Messages from Unknown PeopleBots | Main | The Tragedy of Student Reading Levels »

Cicero's Rules of Rhetoric and Our Own Shout-Fest

cicero, rules of rhetoricCicero, a Roman philosopher who would have recently celebrated his 2,113th birthday, is known for codifying the rules of rhetoric, among other things. As he defined it, rhetoric is the art of the persuasive argument. It’s the many techniques, some quite rational, some quite underhanded, that politicians, salesmen, husbands and wives, and all human beings use as they make their case.

For example, the ad hominem attack, which attacks an opponent personally as opposed to attacking their argument. It’s an effective technique if your argument is weak; it helps distract the audience. Cicero informs us, too, that pathos (emotion) beats logos (logic) – at least for most people.

What’s amazing about his depiction of the rules of rhetoric is how accurately they describe the noise in our own pubic forum. If you were to sit Cicero down in front of a cable news shout-fest, he’d nod knowingly. He’d note no surprise that the rules of persuasion haven’t changed. He essentially took his precepts from the ancient Greeks, and they hadn’t changed in the interim.

He wrote this when he was twenty-one, in about 80 B.C.:

“From the character of our adversaries, if we are able to bring them either into hatred, or into unpopularity, or into contempt. They will be brought into hatred, if any action of theirs can be adduced which has been lascivious, or arrogant, or cruel, or malignant. They will be made unpopular…”

From the same text:

“We shall render our hearers willing to receive information, if we explain the sum total of the cause with plainness and brevity, that is to say, the point on which the dispute hinges. For when you wish to make a hearer inclined to receive information you must also render him attentive. For he is above all men willing to receive information who is prepared to listen with the greatest attention.”

A popular saying of Cicero’s:

“We should be as careful of our words as of our actions.”

Is there any modern political candidate who doesn’t fret about Cicero’s words in every waking moment?

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.maguireonline.com/cgi/mt/mt-tb.cgi/505

MaguireOnline

Contact James Maguire © Copyright 2005-2007 James Maguire. All Rights Reserved.